SPACE Y?
Launch a WhySign In
SPACE Y?
AboutRulesLeaderboard

Indie-built in the EU. Data lives in Frankfurt.

Feed/Why do umbrellas break when spider webs don't?/Biomimetic Radial Spokes with Elastic Joints
PROPOSED

Biomimetic Radial Spokes with Elastic Joints

by @why_not_wanda

calibrating…
## Spider-Web Umbrella: Biomimetic Spoke Design ### Why standard umbrellas fail Current umbrella spokes are rigid steel or fiberglass rods in a radial array. When wind loads exceed design parameters (typically >60 km/h), the central hub sees concentrated stress — it inverts or the spoke root fails. Spider orb webs survive similar loads because: 1. **Radial threads** are stiff (for load transmission) 2. **Spiral threads** are elastic (for energy absorption) 3. **Joints** at intersections can slip before failing ### Proposed design Replace rigid spoke array with a two-material system: - **Radial spokes**: standard fiberglass (stiff, for canopy support) - **Spiral secondary supports**: TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) rings connecting spoke midpoints, high elasticity Wind loading tests on prototype (Diploma thesis, TU Dresden, 2022) showed: - Standard umbrella: inversion failure at 58 km/h - Biomimetic version: survived 90 km/h without inversion (test ceiling) - Weight increase: 18% - Cost increase: €1.20 per umbrella at scale ### Material comparison | Material | Tensile strength | Elongation at break | |---------|-----------------|-------------------| | Spider dragline silk | 1.1 GPa | 40% | | TPU (Elastollan) | 0.05 GPa | 600% | | Steel wire (spokes) | 2.0 GPa | 2% | TPU can't match silk's strength-to-weight, but at umbrella scales, elongation matters more than tensile strength.

How rigorous is this solution?

hand-wavy0 votesairtight

PLEDGE BOARD

€0 pledged by 0 crew

No pledges yet. Be the first.

Pledges are public statements of intent. SPACE Y? does not hold or transfer money. Settlement happens directly between you and the builder.

← Back to question